BLAMELESS VICTIMS OF A REVOLUTION GONE AWRY
There was something eerie in the air as the tumbrils passed through the streets of Paris
that led to Place du Trône Renversé. It
was, in fact, too eerie that the normally noisy and violent crowd was "in a
respectful silence such as has never been accorded throughout the Revolution." No rotten fruit was pelted and no clamorous insult
was raised on the condemned women and men. That
evening one only heard the ethereal chanting of sixteen Discalced Carmelite nuns on their
way to death.
These women could hardly be recognized as nuns. Wrapped in their white mantles, they did not, however, wear their veils. Their wimples had been cut away, exposing their necks to facilitate the truculent job of the guillotine's blade.
At around eight in the evening, after a ride of two hours, the tumbrils finally arrived at
the place of execution. A horrid stench of rotting flesh from the common graves in
nearby Picpus and of putrifying blood beneath the scaffold greeted them. The crowd
remained reverently silent. The Carmelites have finally come face to face with the
dreaded guillotine. Led by their courageous prioress, Mo. Thérèse of St.
Augustine, they sang the Christian hymn of praise: You are God: we praise you; You
are the Lord: we acclaim you; You are the eternal Father: all creation worships you
The glorious company of apostles praises you.
The noble fellowship of prophets praises you. The white-robed army of martyrs praises you...
WINDS OF AN INEVITABLE REVOLUTION
Many historians agree that the twentieth century traces its foundations to the events that shook France from 1789 to, strictly speaking, 1795. The French Revolution took place amid an in social disarray. Historian Edward Tannenbaum capsulized: Many people knew that something was wrong. There was an economic crisis aggravated by population pressure; the aristocratic resurgence exasperated sections of the bourgeoisie and the peasantry; enlightened political ideas were raising constitutional issues, and enlightened despotism was not working very well.
With the rising of the masses, an era of radical ideas unconceived beforehand was ushered - equality of all before the law; freedoms of speech, religion and opinion; resistance to oppression; rights to property, security and liberty. A new epoch practically began with this mother of revolutions.
The clash, however, of the old and new orders produced a violent friction. Reforms were plenty, indeed, but violence also abounded, caused by years of bottled hatred or plain paranoia. Soon, freedoms highly idealized by the revolution like choice, conscience and religion were trampled upon. There were too many victims in the process, many of whom were commoners exercising their democratic rights. Among them were the sixteen Carmelites of Compiègne.
The nuns came from every social stratum of French society and each had her unique personality.Taken as a whole, the community does not present an exceptional milieu. Their fathers were a master purse-maker, shoemaker, turner, laborer, clerk, and an employee of the observatory. Only one is a counselor of the king, one a noble squire. Few were blue-blooded; most were commoners. The grille sheltered, both from the psychological and social points of view, a world in a nutshell. The lone novice was of peasant stock, but she had for her formator the grandniece of the great aristocrat Jean-Baptiste Colbert. The pretty and young assistant infirmarian laughed at the whims of the beloved old sister philosopher. The well-balanced prioress had for her assistant a nun passionately in love with the divine office.The Constituent Assembly provisionally suspended the profession of vows in all monasteries on 29 October 1789. Mother Thérèse was distressed that the decree prevented Sr. Constance, the lone novice, from making her profession. She wrote to a former postulant: Sr. Constance remains always a novice here. Troubles have not been lacking on the side of her family: now they do not want her letters anymore or to hear her spoken of. The Lord permits this to be assured of her fidelity, and she accounts herself happy if they leave her in peace as at present. She hopes that the good God will at last touch their hearts and that they will look on her perseverance without sorrow.
THE CIVIL CONSTITUTION OF THE CLERGY
On 12 July 1790, the National Assembly implemented the Civil Constitution of the Clergy. Among its articles was a provision for the suppression of the monastic orders and the liberation of monks and nuns who would choose to renounce their vows. On 15 August, the members of the Directory of the Compiègne district came to the monastery to interrogate each nun and offer her liberty.
The unanimous reply
of the religious was to remain and keep their vows. Some
of the nuns made their declarations more vivid:
fifty-six years I have been a Carmelite. I
desire to have the same number of years more to be consecrated to the Lord. (Sr. of
I became a religious by my own will. I
have made up my mind to go on wearing this habit, even if I have to purchase this joy with
my own blood. (Sr. Euphrasie)
A good spouse desires to remain with her husband. I do not wish to abandon my spouse. (Sr.
Saint Francis Xavier)
If I will be able to double the bonds of my attachment to God, then, with all
my strength and zeal, I will do so. (Sr. Thérèse of the Heart of Mary)
In February of the following year, the nuns were ordered to elect, in the presence of the municipal officers, a prioress and a bursar. Mo. Thérèse was unanimously re-elected; Mo. Henriette was voted bursar. The state then provided the eighteen intern nuns with decent pensions.
ENEMIES OF THE
Another provision of the Civil Constitution of the Clergy required priests and religious to take a loyalty oath that required them to be faithful to the nation, the law and the king; and to maintain the constitution with all their power. What the ambiguous statement meant was that they were to give the revolutionary government the right to control and democratize the Church in complete disregard of Papal jurisdiction. Pope Pius VI issued on 10 March 1791 a condemnation of the Civil Constitution of the Clergy and forbade the clergy to take it. A schism was inevitable. The clergy was split between the juring (those who took the oath) and non-juring bishops and priests.
Two weeks after Easter of 1792, the guillotine was installed in Paris. Everyone was talking about it, even in the Carmel
of Compiègne, and everyone feared it. In September, around 1,400 enemies of the Republic were killed
during the infamous September Massacre; among them were hundreds of non-juring priests.
A belief that they
would all be called to martyrdom someday prevailed in the community. Between June and September of that year, Mo.
Thérèse proposed that the community offer their lives to God with an act of oblation
in order that the divine peace which Christ has brought to the world may be restored
to the Church and to the State. All
promised to unite themselves to it, except for Sr. of Jesus Crucified and Sr. Charlotte of
the Resurrection, the two most senior nuns. Trembling
and fearful that they would end more than fifty years of peaceful life in Carmel with a
bloody death, both withdrew from the community.
Before the day ended, however, they prostrated themselves before the prioress and
tearfully asked forgiveness for their momentary weakness.
All the nuns renewed the act until the very day of their death.
IN SPITE OF DISPERSION
On 14 August 1792, the Convention ordered all French citizens receiving state pension to
take the Oath of Liberté-Egalité which required them to be faithful to the nation
and to maintain liberty and equality or to die defending them. Three days later, all
religious houses were ordered vacated.
At this point in time, the Carmelites of Compiègne had been reduced to nineteen with the death of two sisters. The remaining nuns left the monastery and garbed secular clothes on 14 September 1792. They divided themselves into four groups with the prioress, sub-prioress, bursar and another nun heading each.
On 19 September, with the permission of Fr. Rigaud, their ecclesiastical superior, they
all took the Oath of Liberté-Egalité. Thus,
all, including the tourières, were eligible to receive pension from the state. Only Sr.
Constance, the novice, was excluded from this right because the members of the Directory
of Compiègne did not consider her a full religious.
For two years, each community strove to continue being faithful to their regular observances. The beautiful accord which reigned among all the sisters ensured that each one never deviated from her duties. One could say that obedience was practiced with all the exactitude of the cloister. It was difficult to find a priest to celebrate the Eucharist; nonetheless, the sisters faithfully recited the divine office at the appointed hours. Since their houses were not far apart, they managed to be in frequent contact with one another. Secretly, they sustained the members of the Confraternity of the Scapular and continued its enrollment. The extern sisters continued to buy provisions and to share these out among the different houses. The dynamism of the entire community was sustained by the daily renewal of the act of oblation and the solicitude of Mo. Thérèse.
Situations worsened when Maximilien Robespierre and his henchmen, the radical and fanatical Jacobins, came into power during the summer of 1793. The Committee of Public Safety was established to protect the republic from foreign invasions and to control prices and wages all over the country. Along with this was institutionalized the infamous Reign of Terror. It not only apprehended and punished with death those who refused to be conscripted into the army but also anyone suspected of any unpatriotic behavior or thoughts!
Within its brief one-year and one-month existence, over 300,000 were imprisoned of whom 50,000 were executed by musketry or in the dreaded guillotine or died in prison. France was literally transformed into an abattoir for her own people. Obsession replaced reality as the radical leaders sought to establish a utopistic society.
Anticlericalism reached its apex and, later, the revolution began to take the guise of a religion. First there was the abolition of the Gregorian calendar. Then churches were turned into Temples of Reason. Next, the juring clergy were ordered to marry (about 20,000 heeded). Finally, Robespierre established the Cult of the Supreme Being in an attempt to totally de-christianize France.
In March 1794, Sr. Marie of the Incarnation went to Paris to settle a serious family
problem.Her stay was prolonged until June. Mother Thérèse was also obliged to go to the
capital on 13 June to bid farewell to her old and widowed mother who was to return to
Franche-Comté, the cradle of her family. During that sojourn, the two nuns were by
chance in the streets when tumbrils carrying those to be guillotined passed before
them.Sr. Marie tried to get Mother Thérèse to avoid the sight.The prioress, however,
refused to move:My good sister, allow me the sad consolation of seeing how martyrs
go to their death.Sr. Marie later wrote that two of the condemned fixed a deep gaze
on them as if to say, Soon, you will follow us.
On the evening of 21 June, Mother Thérèse promptly returned by stagecoach to Compiègne.She was met by some of the nuns who informed her that members of the Committee for Revolutionary Surveillance had searched all their four abodes that very morning and seized all their papers.The search continued the following day. A portrait of the guillotined king, a copy of his will, letters from their deported non-juring confessor and scapulars of the Sacred Heart were found and branded seditious.They also took the food prepared for the nuns, depriving them of nourishment that day.
As previously mentioned, nineteen of the Carmelites of Compiègne were still alive by the
middle of 1792.During the time of the arrest, Sr. Marie of the Incarnation was still in
Paris. Since March 1794, Sr. Thérèse of Jesus and Sr. Stanislas of Providence were
in Rosières.Thus only sixteen were arrested. Through the biography written by Sr. Marie,
we were not only able to know much about the arrest and execution of her community (in
this entire chapter, unless noted otherwise, her accounts are enclosed in quotations)but
also about their lives.
Mother Thérèse of St. Augustine
(Marie-Madeleine-Claudine Lidoine; b. 22 September 1752 in Paris), a woman so loved
by God, was serving her second term as prioress when the Revolution struck.
Her correspondences reveal a woman of great human and supernatural qualities.
Mother St. Louis (Marie-Anne-Françoise Brideau; b. 07 December 1751 in Belfort), the sub-prioress, was given to silence and gentleness. She celebrated the divine office with admirable remembrance and exactitude.
Mother Henriette of Jesus (Marie-Françoise de Croissy;b. 18 June 1745 in Paris), the
novice mistress, was the predecessor of Mother Thérèse. She made herself
esteemed for the qualitites of her heart, her tender piety, zeal, the happy combination of
every religious virtue.
Sr. Charlotte of the Resurrection (Anne-Marie-Madeleine Thouret;b. 16 September 1715 in
Mouy, Oise), the most senior member of the community, possessed a lively temperament. Fond
of frequenting balls in her youth, she entered Carmel after a tragic event.She
served as infirmarian to the point of developing a spinal column deformation that she
endured until death.
Sr. of Jesus Crucified (Marie-Anne Piedcourt; b. 09 December 1715 in Paris) was younger
than Sr. Charlotte by a few months but was senior to her by profession. She occupied the
office of sacristan for many years.Speaking about their persecutors, she said: How
can we be angry with them when they open the gates of heaven for us?
Sr. Thérèse of the Heart of Mary (Marie Hanisset; b. 18 January 1742 in Reims), first sister of the turn and third bursar, was endowed with wisdom, prudence and discernment.
Sr. Thérèse of St. Ignatius (Marie-Gabrielle Trezel; b. 04
April 1743 in Compiègne), the hidden treasure of the community, was
undoubtedly a mystic. Asked why she never
brought a book for meditation, she replied: The good God has found me so ignorant
that none but He would be able to instruct me.
Sr. Julie-Louise of Jesus (Rose Cretien de Neuville;
b. 30 December 1741 in Evreux) entered Carmel as a widow. She dreaded the
guillotine but she chose to stay with her sisters.
Sr. Marie-Henriette of Providence (Marie-Annette Pelras; b. 16 June 1760 in Cajarc, Lot), the assitant infirmarian, first entered the Sisters of Charity and Christian Instruction of Nevers but left it for the more secluded Carmelite life. Youngest among the choir nuns, she possessed a most exquisite beauty.
Sr. Euphrasie of the Immaculate Conception
(Marie-Claude-Cyprienne Brard; b. 12 May 1736 in Bourth, Eure),the philosopher
and joie de vivre of the recreation,admitted that she was filled for some time
with resentment against her prioress. She worked very hard on herself that in the end she
was able to overcome her negative disposition.
Along with these ten
choir nuns were three lay sisters. Sr. Marie of the Holy Spirit (Angélique Roussel; b. 03
August 1742 at Fresne-Mazancourt, Somme) was afflicted by atrocious pains throughout her
body, which she heroically bore up until her death. Sr. St. Martha (Marie Dufour, b
02 October 1741 at Bannes, Sarthe) edified her companions with her virtues. Sr. St. Francis Xavier (Elisabeth-Juliette Vérolot;
b. 13 January 1764 at Lignières, Aube) was frank, lively, and full of goodness.
The youngest member of the community was Sr. Constance(Marie-Geneviève Meunier; b.
28 May 1765 at Saint Denis, Seine)Circumstances forced her to remain as a novice for seven
years. Her parents wanted her to return home and even sent the police for this purpose.
Sr. Constance told them: Gentlemen, I thank my parents if, out of love, they fear
the danger that may befall me. Yet nothing except death can separate me from my mothers
The two tourières were blood sisters. Anne-Catherine Soiron (b. 02 February 1742 in Compiègne)tearfully begged the prioress not to let her and her sister be separated from the community during those crucial hours. Thérèse Soiron,(b. 23 January 1748 in Compiègne) possessed such a rare beauty and charming personality that the ill-fated Princess de Lamballe wanted her to be attached to her court. She responded: Madame, even if your Highness would offer me the crown of France, I would prefer to remain in this house, where the good God placed me and where I found the means of salvation which I would not find in the house of your Highness.
On 23 June, the sixteen nuns were forcibly reunited in the Maison de Reclusion, a former monastery of the Visitation Nuns. In the room next to theirs were imprisoned a group of English Benedictine Nuns from Cambrai. The following day, the Carmelites retracted before the town mayor the Oath of Liberté-Égalité they had made thus signing their own death warrant. Meanwhile, their captors waited for instructions from the Committee for Public Safety in Paris.
The three-week imprisonment was very harsh. The food was hardly palatable and the sick were not given any special diet. A few straws on the bare floor served as their beds. The two communities of nuns were forbidden to communicate with each other, yet the abbess of the Benedictines, Mother Mary Blyde, somehow was able to converse with the Carmelites on two occasions. Fresh clothing was denied the nuns, yet they were forbidden to wash their soiled clothes. After many solicitations, they were finally granted a particular day to do their washing - but they never even had the chance to finish their laundry.
At 10:00 a.m. of 12 July, members of the Revolutionary Committee of Compiègne came with orders from Paris to transfer the Carmelites to the dreaded Conciergerie at the capital. Mother Thérèse protested the untimely order.Their civilian clothes had just been put to soak. She requested permission to seek fresh clothing for her sisters to bring along. This was straightforwardly refused. Therefore, the nuns had to go to Paris wearing part of what was once their religious habits, the only dry clothing that was available.
After finishing their
meager repast, the sixteen bade adieu to their Benedictine companions. With hands bound
behind their back, they were herded into two carts for the long journey to Paris. Along with them was arrested a citizen named Mulot
de la Ménardière, accused as an accomplice of the nuns. A great number of women, many of
whom the nuns helped in many ways, sneered at them: They do well to destroy them.
They are useless mouths. Bravo! Bravo! Mother
Thérèse meanwhile calmed Catherine Soiron who was outraged by the way they were being
The caravan arrived at
the Conciergerie between three to four in the afternoon of the following day. With their
hands still tied behind them, the sisters went down one by one and stood waiting in the
prison courtyard. However, the octogenarian Sr. Charlotte, deprived of her crutch and with
no one to assist her, could not descend from the cart. An impatient soldier jumped aboard
and callously threw her upon the paving stones where she laid motionless. Fearing he had
killed her, the soldier lifted up the old nun whose face was covered with blood.
Believe me, she told him, I am not angry with you. On the contrary, I
thank you for not having killed me for if I have died in your hands, I would have been
deprived of the joy and glory of martyrdom.
While waiting for their trial, the nuns occupied themselves with prayers and works of charity. They sought the sick among the imprisoned and attended to them even until late in the night. During daylight, they continued to celebrate the divine office faithfully. The other prisoners woke in the middle of the night hearing the nuns chanting Matins. Sr. Julie-Louise celebrated the feast of Our Lady of Mount Carmel (16 July) by composing a canticle to the tune of the Marsellaise. Mother Thérèse continually supported the sisters with her exemplary courage, calmness, and maternal attention to the needs of their distressed bodies.
At around 9:00 a.m. of
17 July, the sixteen were brought to the Courtroom of Liberty where the Revolutionary
Tribunal performed its functions. They were led before the three judges and the notorious
Antoine Fouquier-Tinville, the Terror's implacable public prosecutor. He read the Act of
With regard the ex-Carmelite religious Lidoine, Thouret, Brard, Dufour and the others, they kept up, although separated by their abodes, anti-revolutionary meetings and cabal among themselves and wish others whom they brought together and, by taking up again their spirit of sisterhood, conspired against the Republic. A voluminous correspondence found in their possession proves that they did not cease to plot against the Revolution. A portrait of Capet [Louis XVI], his will, the hearts, which are the rallying signs of the Vendean rebels, fanatical puerility, accompanied by the letter of an émigré priest dated 1793, proved that they were in correspondence with the external enemies of France. Such are the marks of the Confederacy formed among themselves. They lived under obedience to a superior and, as for their principles and vows, their letters and writings bear witness to them . They are more than a band, an assembly of rebels, with criminal hope of seeing the French people returned to the chains of tyrants and to the slavery of bloodthirsty priests who are impostors as well.
Sr. Marie-Henriette did not fail to ignore the phrase fanatical puerility. She asked Fouquier-Tinville to explain:
What I mean is your
attachment to your childish beliefs, your stupid religious practices.
She then turned to the
other nuns and said to them: My dear Mother and sisters, let us rejoice in the Lord
for this. We are going to die for the cause of our holy religion, our faith, our reliance
in the holy Roman Catholic Church.
addressed the judges: The letters that we have received are from the chaplain of our
house condemned by your law to be deported. These letters contain nothing more than
spiritual advises. At most, if these correspondences be a crime, this should be considered
as mine, not of the community as our Rule forbids the sisters from making any
correspondence, even with their nearest relations, without the permission of their
superior. If therefore you must have a victim, here she is: it is I alone whom you must
strike. My sisters are innocent.
They are your accomplices! was the blunt reply of the presiding judge. In the end, the sixteen were convicted as enemies of the people. A sentence was given: death by guillotine.
The nuns received their penalty with serenity and joy. However, Thérèse Soiron fainted. Tension, fatigue, and lack of sleep and nourishment finally broke her down. The prioress quickly asked a constable for a glass of water for the tourière. When she regained consciousness, Thérèse asked pardon for her weakness and assured them she was ready to be faithful to the end.
After that incident, it became quite clear that the nuns needed something to eat. After all, they had not eaten anything since the break of dawn. With the permission of the prioress, Mother St. Louis bartered a pelisse in exchange for sixteen cups of chocolate. Thus, while the executioner carried out on the other condemned prisoners the last toilet the trimming away of hair and ripping of any clothing that may impede the decapitation of their heads the nuns had the opportunity to dine in common before their execution.
The sentence was to be completed that same evening. The community
was praying the Office for the Dead when they were summoned. The nuns bade farewell to the other prisoners,
among them was a devout Catholic named Blot: How come our dear Blot is crying?
Rather, you should rejoice to see us at the end of our trials. Recommend us well to the
good God and the most holy Virgin that they may assist us in these final hours. We will
pray for you when we are in heaven.
Cloaked in their white
mantles and with hands bound at their backs, the sixteen recollectedly boarded the
tumbrils that would bring them to Place du Trône Renversé where the guillotine awaited
Along the way, priests disguised as sans-culottes gave them absolution. The journey was
but the air was permeated by their solemn chants of the sixteen, singing as
they did in choir: Have mercy on me,
God, in your kindness. In your compassion,
blot out my offense
. Hail, holy Queen, mother of mercy
The guillotine had
been standing for more than a month already at the Barrière du Trône. Upon arriving
there, Sr. Constance suddenly accused herself before Mother Thérèse of not having
finished her divine office.ioress, told her: Be strong, daughter.You will finish it
in Paradise! Twenty-four others were executed that day but we do not know any detail
At the foot of the
scaffold, the prioress asked the executioner if she might die last so that she could
encourage and support her sister. She also asked for a few minutes to prepare them.This
time her requests were granted. They sang once more, invoking the Holy Spirit:
Creator Spirit, come
. Afterward, they all renewed their religious
vows.The ceremony completed, one unknown sister was overheard saying: O my God! I am
just too happy if this little sacrifice calms your wrath and lessens the number of
One by one, from the youngest to the oldest, the nuns were called.
Summoned by her real name, Sr. Constance knelt before Mother Thérèse and asked for her blessing and the permission to die. This being given, the novice kissed a small red-clay statuette of the Virgin and Child that Mother Thérèse had been concealing in her hand.
Sr. Constance mounted
the scaffold singing the psalm the nuns chanted daily to announce their coming into the
house of God: O praise the Lord, all
Her sisters followed:
acclaim him, all you peoples! Strong is his love for us; he is faithful
All the sisters
followed the example of the novice. They each went to their death joining the song of
those waiting for their turn.While the blade of the guillotine snuffed their lives one by
one, the chorus progressed into a decrescendo. As she ascended the scaffold, Sr. of Jesus
Crucified was assisted by the assistants of the executioner.My friends, she
told them, I forgive you with all my heart, as I desire forgiveness from God.
Finally, only one
voice was left.
Madeleine Claudine Lidoine!
Having seen fifteen of
her daughters precede her to the scaffold, Mother Thérèse followed them to the
guillotine. At the sixteenth thud, there was nothing left
but silence. On that day, it was said, more than one religious
vocation was born and just as many conversions took place.
Ten days later, amidst
cacophonous shouts and screams, an infuriated and disillusioned crowd led a man to his
death on the guillotine. Down with the tyrant! they cried. This time, it was
the turn of Maximilien Robespierre. More than a week later, an enervated Antoine
Fouquier-Tinville followed his fate on the very instrument where he had sent hundreds to
their death. And with the inglorious end of these two died, also, the Reign of Terror.
THE DECREE ON THE MARTYRDOM OF
MARIE-MADELEINE-CLAUDINE LIDOINE (THÉRÈSE OF ST. AUGUSTINE) AND HER SIXTEEN COMPANION
MARTYRS WAS PROMULGATED ON 24 JUNE 1905.
THEY WERE BEATIFIED ON 17 MAY 1906.
[ St. Therese
of Lisieux the "Little Flower" I St. Teresa of Avila I St. John of the Cross ]